Confidence when being critiqued
Confidence. It’s what can make or break you as an artist. I don’t mean arrogance. God knows there are enough ‘I’m-god’s-gift-to-art’ assholes out there. No, I mean believing in you and your art.
Now it’s not just thinking your badass, it’s also being sure enough in your skills to take criticism. Constructive criticism is one way you will really be able to improve as an artist. So go grab a buddy and ask them what they really think of your art. You may be surprised by what you hear. If you get one good tip out of it then it was worth it.
The other part of confidence is to know what advice you want to keep or advice you want to politely disregard. Never be rude to someone if they give you a tip you don’t agree with or a criticism that was a little harsh. Also you don’t have to take someone’s advice. You don’t want to make art that is completely void of you, and just full of what everyone else wanted. Just listen and ask yourself “Will this advice strengthen the piece and my intended message?” The answer to that question tells you what you should do.
When it comes to picking a critique buddy, try to avoid picking your spouse or significant other. I have found that you will take the critique more personally, and you will also be either too open or totally closed off to their advice. Also they may be offended if, and when, you don’t take their advice. It’s not that you shouldn’t talk to them about your work, but use them for problem solving and moral support, or in my case heavy lifting (sculptures weigh a lot!).
Hardcore critiquing, I find, works best with a friend who also makes art of some type. To be honest, I am a sculptor by trade and my best critique buddy is my friend who is a graphic designer. It works out perfectly. She is in a different field and brings in a point of view I would never think of to my work. She is 2-D and color oriented and it improves my work in unexpected ways. That’s what you want. You don’t want a monoculture of fellow artists who are all realistic portrait painters. Throw in a welder, or someone who works with watercolor, or a landscape painter.
Diversity is the key. Ask everyone you feel comfortable with to look at your art. And get them to give you an honest opinion. Don’t settle for the ‘oh I like it,’ you want something with meat. Critiquing is not the time to be a vegetarian (which I am) this is the time to demand meat!
When critiquing your work think about color, composition, general style/ technique, and medium. Is the medium working for your piece? (For basic tips on critiquing art check this page out.)
Then do the unintentional references check. No one wants to accidentally reference something and not know it.
Look for any reference to a body part (think Georgia O’Keefe) or another artist or even a religious symbol. Even if the reference doesn’t bother you it is still important to know its there.
Laugh all you want, but if you don’t want it there take it out. Cause if you don’t, someone will see it and focus on it, and wonder whether you are a closet lesbian or a secret religious nut or just some artist who has no idea what there doing or what they’re referencing. Which nobody wants…right?
